Difference between revisions of "Measure type: Physical measures"

From Securipedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m
m
Line 1: Line 1:
 
''Physical measures'' could be used for controlling access, impeding an attack or protective materials.
 
''Physical measures'' could be used for controlling access, impeding an attack or protective materials.
   
The following chart includes various Physical solutions that can be implemented as event driven-measures to mediate the risk of a high-impact crime (such as a terrorist attack) at an event in a designated area.
+
The following chart includes various Physical solutions that can be implemented as event driven-measures to mediate the risk of a high-impact crime (such as a terrorist attack) at an event in a designated area. These are examples derived from the [[PRoTECT research project|PRoTECT]] project.
 
The chart includes various columns:
 
 
In the first column, under ''''Tech description'''<nowiki/>', '''technological solutions''' are listed.
 
 
The next column indicates which '<nowiki/>'''Threat types'''' can be mitigated with these technological solutions:
 
 
# ''Fire arms'' attack - small calibre pistol or semi/full-automatic rifle;
 
# ''Sharp object'' attack - knifes, machete, other sharp and blunt objects;
 
# ''Vehicle'' attack - use of vehicle as a weapon by ramming large crowds;
 
# ''IED'' (explosives) - left/concealed in objects or goods (based on home-made or commercial explosives);
 
# ''PBIED'' (explosives) - explosives concealed on a person (suicide or carrier);
 
# ''UAVIED'' (explosives) - explosives delivered by a remote-controlled airborne device;
 
# ''VBIED'' (explosives) - explosives concealed inside a vehicle (or its cargo);
 
# ''Chemical'' attack - threat object concealed in goods or carried items (e.g. canister or UAV dispensed);
 
# ''Biological'' attack - threat object concealed in goods or carried items (e.g. canister or UAV dispensed);
 
# ''Radiological'' attack - threat object concealed in goods or carried items (e.g. canister or UAV dispensed).
 
 
The 'T'''hreat phase'''' column states in which phase of the attack the technological solution has the most effect:
 
 
# ''Initial Target Identification'' (before the attack);
 
# ''Operational Planning'' (before the attack);
 
# ''Pre-Attack Preparation'' (before the attack);
 
# ''Execution'' (during the attack);
 
# ''Post-Attack/Escape'' (after the attack).
 
 
Finally, the '<nowiki/>'''Tech use'''' column states the appertaining security function of the technological solution:
 
 
# ''Alert'' - used for alerting public (e.g. sirens, texting service);
 
# ''Surveil'' - used for situational awareness (e.g. cameras, social media tools);
 
# ''Respond'' - used for responding to an attack (e.g. security personnel, non-lethal weapons);
 
# ''Protect'' - used to protect assets (people, buildings, infrastructure);
 
# ''Detect'' - used for detecting a weapon or weapon use (e.g. entry scanning equipment);
 
# ''Overcome'' - used for overcoming a sudden vulnerability (e.g. extra concertina wire);
 
# ''Improvise'' - created on the spot from available means (e.g. use police vehicle as a road block);
 
# ''Restrict'' - used for restricting public access (e.g. safety barriers);
 
# ''Adapt'' - used for changing circumstances (e.g. moving assets to a safer location);
 
# ''Other.''
 
   
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
{| class="wikitable"
|'''''Tech description'''''
+
|'''Tech description'''
 
|'''Threat type'''
 
|'''Threat type'''
 
|'''Threat phase'''
 
|'''Threat phase'''
 
|'''Tech use'''
 
|'''Tech use'''
 
|'''Tech criteria'''
 
|'''Tech criteria'''
|'''Products/suppliers'''
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Influence attacker physically (for example, intimidate, Less Lethal Weapons (sound, vision))
 
|Influence attacker physically (for example, intimidate, Less Lethal Weapons (sound, vision))
Line 55: Line 16:
 
<br />
 
<br />
 
|Readiness / Performance
 
|Readiness / Performance
|Psychological Intervention Guide for PBIED attacks: multidimensional matrix of significant aspects of PBIED in crowd,
 
 
facilitates sense making in using softer methods to delay/protect (by TNO, for FP7 SUBCOP)
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Physical barriers that are flexible or permanent
 
|Physical barriers that are flexible or permanent
Line 64: Line 22:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Readiness / performance
 
|Readiness / performance
|Many available
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Urban layout with bollards, planters, et cetera
 
|Urban layout with bollards, planters, et cetera
Line 73: Line 30:
 
<br />
 
<br />
 
|Other: impact, architectural looks
 
|Other: impact, architectural looks
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Reduce the loading on a building by using landscape design
 
|Reduce the loading on a building by using landscape design
Line 83: Line 39:
 
<br />
 
<br />
 
|Cost and other: effectiveness
 
|Cost and other: effectiveness
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Design of roads to prevent the impact of vehicles with a high speed
 
|Design of roads to prevent the impact of vehicles with a high speed
Line 90: Line 45:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
<br />
 
<br />
|n/a
 
 
|n/a
 
|n/a
 
|-
 
|-
Line 99: Line 53:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
<br />
 
<br />
|n/a
 
 
|n/a
 
|n/a
 
|-
 
|-
Line 107: Line 60:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Physical, cost and other: impact on normal operations
 
|Physical, cost and other: impact on normal operations
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Permanent measures – security gate, (blast resistant) fencing, bollards….
 
|Permanent measures – security gate, (blast resistant) fencing, bollards….
Line 114: Line 66:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Physical, cost and other: impact on normal operations
 
|Physical, cost and other: impact on normal operations
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Façade design (include the window and door anchors)
 
|Façade design (include the window and door anchors)
Line 121: Line 72:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Physical / cost
 
|Physical / cost
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Explosion resistant glazing
 
|Explosion resistant glazing
Line 128: Line 78:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Physical / cost
 
|Physical / cost
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Bullet proof glazing
 
|Bullet proof glazing
Line 135: Line 84:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Physical / cost
 
|Physical / cost
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Prevent progressive collapse
 
|Prevent progressive collapse
Line 142: Line 90:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Physical / cost
 
|Physical / cost
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Prevent roof objects like lightning, panels to fall on the people
 
|Prevent roof objects like lightning, panels to fall on the people
Line 149: Line 96:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Physical / cost
 
|Physical / cost
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Provide a safe place for shelter
 
|Provide a safe place for shelter
Line 156: Line 102:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Physical / cost
 
|Physical / cost
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Products to mitigate or reduce the explosion effects like blast container (place them around the threat) to isolate the threat
 
|Products to mitigate or reduce the explosion effects like blast container (place them around the threat) to isolate the threat
Line 164: Line 109:
 
|Protect
 
|Protect
 
|Other: (It might be effective to protect the surrounding, but also has side effects. E.g. additional risk for EOD)
 
|Other: (It might be effective to protect the surrounding, but also has side effects. E.g. additional risk for EOD)
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Personal protection (vest, helmet, gear) to the first responders and security personnel
 
|Personal protection (vest, helmet, gear) to the first responders and security personnel
Line 171: Line 115:
 
|Respond
 
|Respond
 
|Physical / cost / performance
 
|Physical / cost / performance
|n/a
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|Bomb suit (Explosive ordnance) of the first responders and security personnel
 
|Bomb suit (Explosive ordnance) of the first responders and security personnel
Line 178: Line 121:
 
|Respond
 
|Respond
 
|Physical / performance
 
|Physical / performance
|n/a
 
 
|}
 
|}
  +
  +
In the first column, under ''''Tech description'''<nowiki/>', '''technological solutions''' are listed.
  +
  +
  +
  +
The next column indicates which '<nowiki/>'''Threat types'''' can be mitigated with these technological solutions:
  +
  +
  +
  +
#''Fire arms'' attack - small calibre pistol or semi/full-automatic rifle;
  +
#''Sharp object'' attack - knifes, machete, other sharp and blunt objects;
  +
#''Vehicle'' attack - use of vehicle as a weapon by ramming large crowds;
  +
#''IED'' (explosives) - left/concealed in objects or goods (based on home-made or commercial explosives);
  +
#''PBIED'' (explosives) - explosives concealed on a person (suicide or carrier);
  +
#''UAVIED'' (explosives) - explosives delivered by a remote-controlled airborne device;
  +
#''VBIED'' (explosives) - explosives concealed inside a vehicle (or its cargo);
  +
#''Chemical'' attack - threat object concealed in goods or carried items (e.g. canister or UAV dispensed);
  +
#''Biological'' attack - threat object concealed in goods or carried items (e.g. canister or UAV dispensed);
  +
#''Radiological'' attack - threat object concealed in goods or carried items (e.g. canister or UAV dispensed).
  +
  +
The 'T'''hreat phase'''' column states in which phase of the attack the technological solution has the most effect:
  +
  +
#''Initial Target Identification'' (before the attack);
  +
#''Operational Planning'' (before the attack);
  +
#''Pre-Attack Preparation'' (before the attack);
  +
#''Execution'' (during the attack);
  +
#''Post-Attack/Escape'' (after the attack).
  +
  +
Finally, the '<nowiki/>'''Tech use'''' column states the appertaining security function of the technological solution:
  +
  +
  +
  +
#''Alert'' - used for alerting public (e.g. sirens, texting service);
  +
#''Surveil'' - used for situational awareness (e.g. cameras, social media tools);
  +
#''Respond'' - used for responding to an attack (e.g. security personnel, non-lethal weapons);
  +
#''Protect'' - used to protect assets (people, buildings, infrastructure);
  +
#''Detect'' - used for detecting a weapon or weapon use (e.g. entry scanning equipment);
  +
#''Overcome'' - used for overcoming a sudden vulnerability (e.g. extra concertina wire);
  +
#''Improvise'' - created on the spot from available means (e.g. use police vehicle as a road block);
  +
#''Restrict'' - used for restricting public access (e.g. safety barriers);
  +
#''Adapt'' - used for changing circumstances (e.g. moving assets to a safer location);
  +
#''Other.''
  +
 
Other [[Measures|measure types]] are:
 
Other [[Measures|measure types]] are:
   

Revision as of 16:13, 9 November 2020

Physical measures could be used for controlling access, impeding an attack or protective materials.

The following chart includes various Physical solutions that can be implemented as event driven-measures to mediate the risk of a high-impact crime (such as a terrorist attack) at an event in a designated area. These are examples derived from the PRoTECT project.

Tech description Threat type Threat phase Tech use Tech criteria
Influence attacker physically (for example, intimidate, Less Lethal Weapons (sound, vision)) all Execution Respond / restrict


Readiness / Performance
Physical barriers that are flexible or permanent Vehicle attack Pre-attack preparations Protect Readiness / performance
Urban layout with bollards, planters, et cetera Vehicle, VBIED attack Execution


Protect


Other: impact, architectural looks
Reduce the loading on a building by using landscape design


VBIED attack Execution


Protect


Cost and other: effectiveness
Design of roads to prevent the impact of vehicles with a high speed Vehicle, VBIED attack Execution / Post-Attack/Escape Protect


n/a
Prevent crowded places with environment design all Execution


Protect


n/a
Temporary measures – vehicle barriers, checkpoint, road block Vehicle, VBIED attack Execution Protect Physical, cost and other: impact on normal operations
Permanent measures – security gate, (blast resistant) fencing, bollards…. Vehicle, VBIED attack Execution Protect Physical, cost and other: impact on normal operations
Façade design (include the window and door anchors) IED, PBIED, UAVIED, VBIED attack Execution Protect Physical / cost
Explosion resistant glazing IED, PBIED, UAVIED, VBIED attack Execution Protect Physical / cost
Bullet proof glazing Fire arms attack Execution Protect Physical / cost
Prevent progressive collapse IED, PBIED, UAVIED, VBIED attack Execution Protect Physical / cost
Prevent roof objects like lightning, panels to fall on the people IED, PBIED, UAVIED, VBIED attack Execution Protect Physical / cost
Provide a safe place for shelter Fire arms, sharp object attack Execution Protect Physical / cost
Products to mitigate or reduce the explosion effects like blast container (place them around the threat) to isolate the threat


IED, PBIED attack Execution Protect Other: (It might be effective to protect the surrounding, but also has side effects. E.g. additional risk for EOD)
Personal protection (vest, helmet, gear) to the first responders and security personnel Fire arms, sharp object attack Pre-attack preparations / Execution Respond Physical / cost / performance
Bomb suit (Explosive ordnance) of the first responders and security personnel IED, PBIED, UAVIED, VBIED attack Execution / Post-Attack/Escape Respond Physical / performance

In the first column, under 'Tech description', technological solutions are listed.


The next column indicates which 'Threat types' can be mitigated with these technological solutions:


  1. Fire arms attack - small calibre pistol or semi/full-automatic rifle;
  2. Sharp object attack - knifes, machete, other sharp and blunt objects;
  3. Vehicle attack - use of vehicle as a weapon by ramming large crowds;
  4. IED (explosives) - left/concealed in objects or goods (based on home-made or commercial explosives);
  5. PBIED (explosives) - explosives concealed on a person (suicide or carrier);
  6. UAVIED (explosives) - explosives delivered by a remote-controlled airborne device;
  7. VBIED (explosives) - explosives concealed inside a vehicle (or its cargo);
  8. Chemical attack - threat object concealed in goods or carried items (e.g. canister or UAV dispensed);
  9. Biological attack - threat object concealed in goods or carried items (e.g. canister or UAV dispensed);
  10. Radiological attack - threat object concealed in goods or carried items (e.g. canister or UAV dispensed).

The 'Threat phase' column states in which phase of the attack the technological solution has the most effect:

  1. Initial Target Identification (before the attack);
  2. Operational Planning (before the attack);
  3. Pre-Attack Preparation (before the attack);
  4. Execution (during the attack);
  5. Post-Attack/Escape (after the attack).

Finally, the 'Tech use' column states the appertaining security function of the technological solution:


  1. Alert - used for alerting public (e.g. sirens, texting service);
  2. Surveil - used for situational awareness (e.g. cameras, social media tools);
  3. Respond - used for responding to an attack (e.g. security personnel, non-lethal weapons);
  4. Protect - used to protect assets (people, buildings, infrastructure);
  5. Detect - used for detecting a weapon or weapon use (e.g. entry scanning equipment);
  6. Overcome - used for overcoming a sudden vulnerability (e.g. extra concertina wire);
  7. Improvise - created on the spot from available means (e.g. use police vehicle as a road block);
  8. Restrict - used for restricting public access (e.g. safety barriers);
  9. Adapt - used for changing circumstances (e.g. moving assets to a safer location);
  10. Other.

Other measure types are: